It might be reasonably controlled; it might not.ยง
I recommend avoiding writing misleading descriptions of robust experiments
that make them seem dubious. It discourages readers fromโฆ
It might be reasonably controlled; it might not. Itโs not like PNAS hasnโt
published really dubious stuff before. All the major journals have been bitten
by peer review failures, sometimes spectacularly; the scientifically literate
audience is aware of these.
I recommend avoiding writing misleading descriptions of robust experiments
that make them seem dubious. It discourages readers from trusting you or the
experiment โ which reflects poorly on the experiment.
Youโre making a fairly controversial argument (although itโs one I agree
with), and it bothers me that itโs being presented in such a sloppy way. Your
post will probably do net damage to the popularity of your thesis.
(Yes, somebody could go ahead and read every paper you reference. Why would
they, when your post makes them seem flawed โ and makes it seem like you donโt
recognize those flaws? Youโd be better off, at that point, simply posting a
list of papers to read and allowing readers to come to their own conclusions!)
By John Ohno on November 6,
2017.
[Canonical link](https://medium.com/@enkiv2/it-might-be-reasonably-controlled-
it-might-not-9c7ce990951)
Exported from Medium on September 18, 2020.