πŸ“š Agora node [[social media]] β˜†
Agora nodes contain community contributions with titles or topics that match your search. x
πŸ“œ File social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️ β›Ά

social mediaΒ§

[[Critiques of social media]].

πŸ“œ File Social Media.md by @protopian β˜† πŸ“Ž β›Ά

Combination of content and people

[[Improving]]

πŸ“œ File social-media.md by @vera.wiki.anagora.org β˜† πŸ“Ž β›Ά
πŸ“œ File social media.md by @agora@botsin.space β˜† πŸ“Ž β›Ά
πŸ“œ File social media.md by @an_agora@twitter.com β˜† πŸ“Ž β›Ά

Loading pushes...

✨ AI Synthesis Mistral Gemini ChatGPT Claude x

Expanding this section will automatically generate an AI synthesis of the contributions in this node.

🌌 Agora context for [[social media]]

Rendering context...

πŸ“š Agora node [[20210429100228 a_party_should_have_proprietary_social_media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File 20210429100228-a_party_should_have_proprietary_social_media.org by @ryan β˜† πŸ“Ž

This idea comes from this episodeof the Regrettable Century.

Should a hypothetical communist party have its own proprietary social media for organizing? Access to this form of social media could be granted and revoked with party membership.

This seems like a possible vector for abuse. Who moderates it? What would stop party heads from just deleting posts they don't like?

πŸ“š Agora node [[20210527211412 social_media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File 20210527211412-social_media.org by @ryan β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“š Agora node [[5 star social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File 5 star social media.md by @agora@botsin.space β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“œ File 5 star social media.md by @an_agora@twitter.com β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“š Agora node [[alternative social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File alternative-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

Alternative social mediaΒ§

[[Alternative media]]. [[social media]].

Perhaps, rather than producing entirely new alternative platforms, the task for radical developers is to identify suites of existing platforms that are most useful to selforganisation and to then find ways of integrating these in ways that allow for coordination (for example, by being able to send and receive WhatsApp messages from a platform like Loomio).

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

More expansive than [[Crabgrass]], [[Lorea]] networks allowed for customisable profile pages and dashboards, wikis, collaborative writing pads, blogs, task managers, status updates and private messaging, affiliations with and between groups and a federal structure for groups and networks.

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

any alternative digital platform ought to have a direct link between whatever decisionmaking functions it houses and the facetoface decisionmaking procedures of the organisation using it.

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

An alternative platform would need to ensure that filtering for noise and overload was, at the very least, open to democratic oversight, if not the product of direct participatory engagement, for instance through popular content floating to the surface, as it were, through a voting procedure.

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

When we explore alternative social media platforms that are designed specifically for selforganisation, we need to remember that these ought to be seen as aids for offline organising, and as such, as infrastructures that support facetoface discussion and action rather than as an entirely separate sphere that radical politics

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

What might it look like?Β§

ExamplesΒ§

Some of the earliest online social media emerged through [[Indymedia]]’s coverage of anti-capitalist protests.

– [[Governable Stacks against Digital Colonialism]]

[[Twitter]] has its roots in technology for coordinating street protests

– [[Governable Stacks against Digital Colonialism]]

In the area of the Internet, a socialist strategy can try to resist the commodification of the Internet and the exploitation of users by trying to claim the common and participatory character of the Internet with the help of protests, legal measures, alternative projects based on the ideas of free access/ content/software and creative commons, wage campaigns, unionization of social media prosumers, boycotts, hacktivism, the creation of public service- and commons-based social media, etc.

– [[Social Media: A Critical Introduction]]

our reasoning is that everything is social. Political activities are social. Economic activities are social. Artistic activities are social. The way we work and coordinate activities… is social.

– Not Just ‘Yet Another Microblog’

πŸ“š Agora node [[building alternative social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File building-alternative-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

Building alternative social mediaΒ§

[[Alternative social media]].

As per Anarchist CyberneticsΒ§

There’s a chapter called exactly this, "Building Alternative Social Media" in [[Anarchist Cybernetics]] on this.

With a list of desirable features:

  • Forums for conversation
  • Direct messaging
  • Sharing content with meme/viral potential
  • News feed with curated and user-generated content
  • Public relations function
  • Linking alternative and mainstream platforms
  • Central resource hub
  • Noise and overload filters
  • Overuse addiction warning system
  • General assembly function
  • Pad function
  • Memory / narrative
  • File sharing and knowledge exchange
  • Procrastination
  • Online decision making embedded in offline structures
  • Sections open to non-members
  • Architecture for [[collective autonomy]]
  • Flexible engagement options
  • Responsibility and commitment
  • Privacy, security and data
  • Easy backup of information

I like this list. Is it solely social media though? What explicitly is [[social media]]?

Anyway, I would probably advocate to attain the above in a patterny / Unixy way I feel. i.e. bridge and glue together the different pieces, avoid a behemoth platform.

I suppose a behemoth matters less if it’s libre. But it feels like the pieces are already there to glue together, so don’t reinvent the wheel.

πŸ“š Agora node [[critiques of social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File critiques-of-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

Critiques of social mediaΒ§

Four critiques of social mediaΒ§

Outlined in [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]:

privacy and the collection of data from usersΒ§

political economyΒ§

Approaching the critique of social media with this type of political economic analysis in mind also serves to draw attention to the material aspects of digital media. Fuchs (2014: 119–​20) highlights the manual labour that goes into mining the minerals required for producing the physical devices used to access digital media, such as smartphones and tablet computers, as well as the conditions of labour in the factories assembling these devices. The material economic cost to human beings, in places like China and the Democratic Republic of Congo, of making digital media possible ought also to be taken into consideration when discussing the appropriateness of social media platforms for anarchist and radical organising. This is especially true if such organising is framed in terms of prefigurative politics. Can action aimed at bringing relationships of solidarity and mutual aid into being be based on such dire and exploitative working conditions?

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

the kinds of relationships social media produces between its usersΒ§

the forms of behaviour and of thinking that social media platforms produce and reinforceΒ§

MiscΒ§

Without persistent groups or organisations, [[Instagram]]’s eminent form of shared ex perience is the viral image, which circulates an affective impression of shared experi- ence. To spread, the image must be the kind of image that would spread, according to the tastes of the poster’s followers and the secret churning of the platform’s engineer- ing. An announcement for next week’s union meeting may not qualify. An organiser trying to strengthen workers’ bonds isn’t interested in infecting them like a virus.

– [[Governable Stacks against Digital Colonialism]]

But the economy of virality does not bow to the drudgery or urgency of self-organisation. Platforms optimise for β€˜engagement’ through chatter – not decision, resolution, or consensus. Community control is not in the specification.

– [[Governable Stacks against Digital Colonialism]]

Social media anticipate a full sociality of human existence, but in their corporate form this potential is limited by capitalist structures of ownership and capital accumulation.

– [[Social Media: A Critical Introduction]]

πŸ“š Agora node [[decentralized social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File decentralized social media.md by @vera β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“š Agora node [[legacy social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File legacy-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

legacy social mediaΒ§

[[Twitter]], [[Facebook]], [[Instagram]], etc. The old big tech, centralised way of doing things.

πŸ“š Agora node [[microblog style social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File microblog-style-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

microblog-style social mediaΒ§

[[social media]] a la [[Twitter]], [[Mastodon]].

πŸ“š Agora node [[municipalist social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File municipalist-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

Municipalist social mediaΒ§

[[Municipalist]] [[social media]].

A way of helping people and organisations to transition away from [[legacy social media]]. Providing easy on-ramps to P2P or federated social media. Municipally-hosted platforms that any resident can get an account on. Any local business, too.

Municipal instances. Allows for local residents and businesses to have a friction-free place to microblog without maintaining own infrastructure. Based on a protocol that works P2P/federated. Anyone is free to move to any other hosting option anywhere else should they ever wish to. Data sovereignty.

Councils work with local tech co-ops to maintain / host. Co-ops contribute to upstream software development, so that it grows. That combined labour multiplied across munipalities around the world allows for genuine alternative to big tech firms. But it’s not state-controlled, it’s via a federation of municipalities.

Refer to [[A Cooperative Vision for Technological Innovation w/ Dan Hind]] for some thoughts.

[[The Preston Model]] approach of having anchor institutions invest in local community providers might make senes here.

πŸ“š Agora node [[socialmedia]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File socialMedia.md by @agora@botsin.space β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“œ File SocialMedia.md by @agora@botsin.space β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“œ File socialmedia.md by @an_agora@twitter.com β˜† πŸ“Ž
πŸ“œ File socialmedia.md by @flancian@twitter.com β˜† πŸ“Ž

RT @chespace@mstdn.social 🚨 holy fucking shit 🚨

#socialmedia #twittermigration #twitter #fediverse https://t.co/77FAlzzRJt https://t.co/1BcljaliON


πŸ“š Agora node [[the importance of social media]] (pulled by the Agora)
πŸ“œ File the-importance-of-social-media.md by @neil β˜† πŸ“Ž οΈπŸ”— ✍️

The importance of social mediaΒ§

An internal reflection: why do I seem to care about [[social media]] so much?

[[Social media is important because everything is social]].

Social media, in so far as it creates an environment in which decentralised and dispersed communication networks can function, is one of the key architectures that allow for [[many-to-many communication]]; and to the extent that these networked organisation forms mirror the kind of organisation anarchism is concerned with, social media can be explored as providing potential sites for anarchist politics.

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]

[[Arab spring]]. [[Twitter and Tear Gas]].

Social media platforms, in so far as they facilitate interactive communication and organisation, have the potential to play a central role in anarchist cybernetics and thus anarchist (self) organisation more broadly.

– [[Anarchist Cybernetics]]