TODO break this note up further!
Give each task your undivided attention
Multitasking is not a good idea
It may appear that (or I may think that) I'm good at doing multiple things at the same time, but in truth I'm not. The book cites a number of studies to back this up, but I already know this for myself!
The goal should be distraction-free writing
Writing should be as distraction-free as driving (or in my case, coding too!)
Give each task the right kind of attention
Academic writing require s a whole spectrum of attention. It requires flexibility and context-switching (say, going from the ability to write a coherent argument to the ability to proofread and critique one)
"Floating" attention is required while processing the zettelkasten
Become an expert instead of a planner
To be able to become an expert we need the freedom to learn it on our own terms
Is this why it's easier for me to learn a programming language by actually writing it than by reading about it?
Beginners must adhere to rigid rules that they are taught, while experts are able to use their experience to make informed decisions. The transition between these two mindsets is the difference between beginner and expert:
Because trainees lack the experience to judge a situation correctly and confidently, they need to stick to the rules they were taught, much to the delight of their teachers. According to the Dreyfuses, the correct application of teachable rules enables you to become a competent “performer” (which corresponds to a “3” on their five-grade expert scale), but it won’t make you a “master” (level 4) and certainly won’t turn you into an “expert” (level 5).
Experts, on the other hand, have internalised the necessary knowledge so they don’t have to actively remember rules or think consciously about their choices. They have acquired enough experience in various situations to be able to rely on their intuition to know what to do in which kind of situation. Their decisions in complex situations are explicitly not made by long rational-analytical considerations, but rather come from the gut (cf. Gigerenzer, 2008a, 2008b).
Expert chess players think less than beginners: they see patterns and let themselves be guided by their experience
This isn't to say that rules don't matter, but we should be critical of rules
Get closure
It's easier to remember things we understand
Things we understand are connected
The example the book uses provides a list of years the World Cup occurred on ordered consecutively. If we understand that we can make sense of the data and therefore remember it
Every new note we (I) write should be accompanied with the following questions:
How does this fact fit into my idea of … ?
Are these two ideas contradictory or do they compliment each other?
Isn't this argument similar to that one?
Haven't I heard this before?
What does x mean for y?
Zeigarnik effect: Open tasks tend to occupy short-term memory until they are done
We don't have to finish tasks to no longer be distracted by them, we just have to find some sort of closure, i.e. write it down
The book Getting Things Donetalks about this
We can use this effect to our advantage, however, by continuing to visit the last open question. Pondering the last open item while doing other things is a good way to find answers or solve problems. (Becoming obsessive about it, however, is probably a bad idea)
Reduce the number of decisions
Willpower and motivation should be seen as a limited resource rather than a character trait
Decision-making is anathema to motivation; it is a completely draining task. Therefore, decisions should be reduced
The slip-box, through its lack of categories, reduces the number of decisions one must make
Being able to pick up a task where it was left, and being able to take breaks, is also important
Read with a pen in hand
To write a good paper you must rewrite a good draft
To write a good draft you must turn good notes into continuous text
The idea isn't to copy but to have meaningful dialogue with the text you read (I more or less copied this text though!)
Luhmann would always read with the intention of trying to connect what he's reading with what is in his slip-box
Literature notes are a tool for understanding and grasping text
New ideas will necessitate lengthier literature notes, but what we have to keep in mind is that they should only serve as a temporary stop on the way to becoming a permanent note. Literature notes should first and foremost serve to support the writing of permanent notes.
How extensive the literature notes should be really depends on the text and what we need it for. It also depends on our ability to be concise, the complexity of the text and how difficult it is to understand. As literature notes are also a tool for understanding and grasping the text, more elaborate notes make sense in more challenging cases, while in easier cases it might be sufficient to just jot down some keywords. Luhmann, certainly being on the outer spectrum of expertise, contented himself with pretty short notes and was still able to turn them into valuable slip-box notes without distorting the meaning of the original texts.[27] It is mainly a matter of having an extensive latticework of mental models or theories in our heads that enable us to identify and describe the main ideas quickly (cf. Rickheit and Sichelschmidt, 1999). Whenever we explore a new, unfamiliar subject, our notes will tend to be more extensive, but we shouldn’t get nervous about it, as this is the deliberate practice of understanding we cannot skip. Sometimes it is necessary to slowly work our way through a difficult text and sometimes it is enough to reduce a whole book to a single sentence. The only thing that matters is that these notes provide the best possible support for the next step, the writing of the actual slip-box notes. And what is most helpful is to reflect on the frame, the theoretical background, methodological approach or perspective of the text we read. That often means to reflect as much on what is not mentioned as what is mentioned.
This section once again recommends taking notes by hand. I must get a notebook!
Keep an open mind
Don't let your own biases get in the way of new information!
If insight becomes a threat to your writing, you're doing it wrong!
Insight should seek to correct your understanding, so that you're constantly fighting confirmation bias
Instead of staring with a hypothesis and going from there, we should:
Confirm that we have separated tasks and focus on understanding the text we have read
Make sure we've given a true account of its content
Find the relevance of it and make connections
Something should not go into the slip-box unless it adds to the discussion of what's already in the slip-box!
Get the gist
It's important to be able to distinguish between relevant and irrelevant information
"The ability to use one's understanding is a challenge, not a given."
Learn to Read
It's important to take notes in your own words, because then it shows how well you understand what you're reading
Zettelkasten is an external system that forces us to confront what we know and don't know and be honest about it
Learn by reading
Learning requires effort. As Marx says, there is no royal road to science.
Writing should be an act of learning
The slip-box is complementary to learning: it serves as long-term memory and references. The brain is supposed to be the thing that ties all the information together!
experienced readers tend to engage with a text with questions in mind, see how it relates to other things they've read, etc.
Writing every day helps, but writing for writing's sake is insufficient for academic writing
Luhmann wrote six notes a day, on average
Granted he was an academic!
Writing concepts down and then forgetting them is integral to the process of long-term learning
We should focus on making connections, maximizing information "retrieval strength" to maximize learning
Adding permanent notes to the slip-box is an integral step to taking smart notes
The goal is to "build a latticework of mental models"
The slip-box is not an encyclopedia, we do not need to worry about completeness
Luhmann would only add two "tags" per note
Luhmann's tags corresponded to an index though. org-roam makes it a little more free
The organization of notes lies in their ability to reference one another. Some connections may be surprising
The archivist asks "Which keyword is most fitting?" while the writer asks "Under which circumstances do I want to find this note again?"
Comparing notes helps to detect contradictions or paradoxes, which indicate that an idea hasn't been fully developed yet
The slip-box should be a creativity machine!
New ideas are generated out of intuition, and the slip box is there to help facilitate that
Creativity comes from seeing associations
To be able to play with ideas we have to be able to abstractideas from their original context
Abstraction and re-specification allow us to apply ideas in new situations
Make sure you describe notes in the slip box as plainly as possible and describe it as you understand it
We might not know what's missing from our notes, but we can take guesses as to what would be relevant
The book goes into an anecdote about survivorship bias i.e. Abraham Wald suggested that the Royal Air Force armor all the places planes hadn't been hit, because the ones that had been hit didn't make it back
Take simple ideas seriously
The book recommends taking digital notes as though the space were limited and limiting yourself to one note per idea
I'm not sure how to square this with org-roam yet!
literature notesare basically "on page x, it says y"
Self-imposed restrictions like the one above can make thinking and creativity flourish
A clear structure allows us to explore the internal possibilities of something
Writing makes you realize where the holes in your knowledge are
Research projects ought to be flexible
The slip-box should always be there to give you lots of different research topics, so if you get stuck you can move onto something else
When it comes to writing, you should try and consider writing only for yourself first
If there is one piece of advice that is worth giving, it is to keep in mind that the first draft is only the first draft. Slavoj Žižek said in an interview that he wouldn’t be able to write a single sentence if he didn’t start by convincing himself he was only writing down some ideas for himself, and that maybe he could turn it into something publishable later. By the time he stopped writing, he was always surprised to find that the only thing left to do was revise the draft he already had.
A : [[book]]
Written by : [[Bob Doto]]
Bob presents a [[system]] for [[writing]] - the [[Zettelkasten]] method.
[[personal knowledge management]].
The mind is for having ideas, not holding them (David Allen)
Some tension with spaced repetition etc? In that spaced repetition is all about trying to hold ideas in the mind.
if your zettelkasten is filled with every random thought you have, in whatever unedited state you capture it, your zettelkasten will soon become an unpleasant place to visit. Engaging with the slip box should feel exciting, not anxiety-producing.
Do i do this? The notes in my journal are closer to fleeting notes than main notes. That’s OK though, I think. Journals are OK for that purpose.
Note-taking is writing, and writing is a path toward knowing
Why take notes? It helps you to understand what you think about things.
Taking notes marks the beginning of the externalization process
fleeting notes must be transformed into main notes if they’re to become useful
The most important thing about any form of reference note-making is to, at some point, return to the note
If you’re using a digital platform, create a folder within your “Zettelkasten” folder titled “Reference Notes.
Do i really need a separate folder?
They’re the fundamental building blocks of your future writing and the primary components with which you will develop and challenge your thinking
Main notes. I think I’ve been using claims for roughly this.
To enhance the value of captured facts, it’s best to rephrase them in your own words
The more you integrate a fact into your own thinking, the more likely the fact will find its way into the broader network of ideas stored in your zettelkasten
Rephrase facts in your own words
Note makers sometimes question whether facts should coexist with personal thoughts, because facts appear less valuable. When copied from a source, facts are essentially quotes, especially when copying someone else’s words. Accumulating uncontextualized facts leads to a network of other people’s concepts, which will not necessarily improve your writing. To enhance the value of captured facts, it’s best to rephrase them in your own words.
There’s benefits to doing folgezettel even if you’re using a digital system that doesn’t need them as ids per se
[[Folgezettel makes you consider your new notes more carefully]].
so too is folgezettel a form of “eufriction,” a slowing down to better engage with the work in front of you. Having to manually apply alphanumeric IDs to notes decelerates the note-making process just enough to force you to think about what you’re doing. It builds good habits. It strengthens mental connections. It’s the kind of friction needed to help those who tend to dump links in their notes without taking the time to convey why they’ve done so
I use [[as of the time of writing]] a lot.
Does hashtag #AOTTOW have legs?
[](nonprofit funding.md)
[](flancia social impact.md)
Backlinks last generated 2022-01-28 07:55:20
Go back to [[Building AI-powered Chatbots with Watson]] or the [[Main AI Page]], or consider an alternative take on Chatbot conversation design from the [[Feminist Chatbot course’s]] page on [[Conversation Design]]
Consider the audience and purpose of the chatbot


I’ve always liked writing. Back when I was a kid, writing may have even seemed easier to me than speaking at times; I wasn’t a particularly good speaker then, and I’m not one now, although I’ve found ways to cope. I slur my words a bit, my voice is a bit nasal, I sometimes even stutter; I’m not a great listen. Writing works around all this and more.
When I became a teenager I liked the idea of writing for a career, but it didn’t happen. I’ve written several first pages of novels, that’s for sure. But for some reason no second or subsequent pages, ever. For some time I thought that it was just that I liked the idea of writing more than writing itself, as I’m sure is relatively common among people. Surely that was a component, but now I wonder if it was also that I just didn’t have anything to say back then. Now I feel more compelled to writing down my thoughts; perhaps because, at some level, I know that now (in my 30s) my thoughts are starting to become what they will be; no longer I’m mostly potential, but I’ve reached a point in which I can start to think that my thought patterns are becoming fixed.
This dude is a bit.. overly passionate about why he thinks [[Obsidian]] is better than [[Roam]].
I don’t have a horse in that race. But his points on outlining vs writing, and databasing vs writing, are interesting.
I don’t think he actually said in what way Obsidian is better for writing. But he says Roam is good for ‘connector databasers’, and Obsidian is good for ‘connector writers’.
It’s been on my mind for a while as to how I can best use org-roam for writing.
Go to the [[Python Week 4 Main Page]] or the [[Python - Main Page]] Also see the [[Programming Main Page]] or the [[Main AI Page]]
See [[Python file handling - reading]]
For code examples see [[Week4 Writing to Files Lab]]
This time we use w for write mode.
with open("/resources/data/Example2.txt", "w") as File1:
File1.write("This is line A")
This will write This is line A to the first line of the file, overwriting whatever was there before.
Successive calls of .write() will write to a new line in the file.
Using a mode will append lines to the end of an existing file.
It is also common to use for loops to add list or dictionary elements to a file.
with open("/resources/data/Example2.txt", "a") as File1:
for item in source_list:
File1.write(item)
You can nest file context managers to perform functions such as copying the contents of one file to another. See the graphic below.

The advice from "The Elements of Style" by Strunk and White and "On Writing Well" by Zinsser. The primary philosophy is that if you can’t write well, then you haven’t thought it through. The act of writing is an act of reasoning.

In other words, the foraging, summarizing, and linking parts of the process are often separated by weeks.
Kind of similar to [[progressive summarisation]].
Where do I [[start writing]]? As I write in the Agora I feel like I might be finding it harder and harder to know where to start individual pieces, and where to end them; it might have to do with the fact that I’ve spent the last two years focused on cross-linking (building relationships) more than in longer form writing. Perhaps this focus has reshaped my brain somewhat; or perhaps writing has always been hard, and this is just a [[narrative]].
a specialized form of communication that translates complex, specialized information into clear, easy-to-understand content. Its primary purpose is to instruct, inform, or guide readers so they can successfully perform a task or understand a concept without frustration.
the people writing…
Labor upsets related to technological changes do occur. There’s no rule saying that employment rates need to return to normal, but at…
The key thing here is not that this time is different than the 60s, or that the people writing about this problem in the 60s were wrong. The state of technological optimism about AI has fluctuated over the years, but has almost never corresponded well with the reality of AI advancement. The people talking about this in the 60s were right, aside from the timeframe — because what everyone in 1959 thought would be normal in 1965 actually happened in 1995 and became normal in 2005.
Labor upsets related to technological changes do occur. There’s no rule saying that employment rates need to return to normal, but at least in a capitalist society, there are forces that encourage it (and capitalism is all about this kind cybernetic feedback). When a job is genuinely completely automated in such a way that, outside of the novelty or nostalgia factor of having a human make it (artisanal production), automated production is always preferable in terms of both price and quality, we can consider that a ‘functional singularity’ of that job — the machine has taken over that job, and humans aren’t going to take it back. Functional singularities happen all the time, and aren’t new. The first industrial revolution spawned luddites in part because a lot of cottage industries were undergoing functional singularities — machines can weave ornately patterned textiles better than humans, so jaquard looms really did take over the extremely specialized and skilled job of expert weavers in that context. Functional singularities happen at a smaller scale all the time, as well — think of the invention of sliced bread — and they are often viewed in a positive light as labor-saving devices, because they often take over tasks that had already been shouldered by the consumer (or by the housewife, or by servants — think sliced bread again, and the dishwasher, the washing machine, and the microwave). Indeed, the very first computers represented a functional singularity of the job of the ‘computer’ — a single computing machine took over the jobs of twenty or thirty young women with mechanical desk calculators; electromechanical telephone exchanges did the same for operators (again typically young women).
Historically, a functional singularity has been considered a labor-saving advancement by people who value the labor in question moreso than the livelihood of the people performing the labor. This is purely a market-related concern — if these people could fall back on a living wage once their tasks were replaced, it wouldn’t really be a concern that their task had been automated (because if they were doing it for some reason other than the money — say, because they got satisfaction from the work — they could continue doing it despite it no longer being profitable).
It takes time for new types of labor to appear in the wake of a functional singularity. To the extent that the ability to perform a task is specialized and full of non-transferrable skills, retraining time is time when the people who were doing the tasks are unemployed. And, even if we assume that such a thing always does happen, the rate at which it happens is clearly not strongly associated with the rate at which jobs are fully automated or the amount of skill displaced. The industrial revolution is so-called because of the vast amount of labor that was displaced, much of it skilled labor — and the various labor movements and luddite-style anti-automation movements of the era are the kind of thing that happen when so much labor is displaced. It’s important to note that the labor movements spawned by the industrial revolution took about a hundred years to get to the point where they are today, and mostly haven’t progressed since — we’re talking about a time scale wherein, historically, most of the displaced people who were the impetus for reforms did not live long enough to benefit from them, and remained displaced or operating in a diminished capacity (say, formerly highly-skilled weavers operating in the unskilled and less lucrative position of pulling a lever) for the remainder of their lives. Neither comparable new fields of labor nor reforms for improving their quality of life caught up to them in time to make any difference — theirs is a story of a lost livelihood.
We really need to be putting these measures in place preemptively, because doing so in a reactionary way will doom another generation to that generation’s equivalent of shit jobs — if even that. Many skilled jobs are on the cusp of replacement, and the unskilled jobs of today (retail, fast food) are already beginning to be replaced. Just as lever-pulling unskilled jobs were not numerous enough to replace the influx of displaced skilled cottage industry workers during the industrial revolution, there simply isn’t room to make every laid-off knowledge worker into a fry cook or grocery bagger — so, without improving the social safety net, expect a large increase in the homeless-and-hungry population. In the end, it doesn’t much matter when exactly the day fully comes, because progress toward total automation is happening, and displacement rates are already higher than reskilling rates.
By John Ohno on May 27, 2015.
[Canonical link](https://medium.com/@enkiv2/the-key-thing-here-is-not-that- this-time-is-different-than-the-60s-or-that-the-people-writing-a44c7f62430e)
Exported from Medium on September 18, 2020.
This is a post about the current election. I didn’t want to write it, for several reasons. One is that none of my insights are my own, and…
This is a post about the current election. I didn’t want to write it, for several reasons. One is that none of my insights are my own, and I expected to see lots of other people making them. Another is that I don’t particularly like making or seeing political posts — even political posts that I generally agree with make me irrationally angry, because they stir up all that stressful tribal instinct. The third reason is that posting about american elections doesn’t and can’t really shed any light on my genuine political positions, because I’ve never seen a political system that really lent itself to the way I feel about politics. However, because somehow nobody is making the arguments that seem obvious to me, I’m going to have to make them, with the caveat that readers probably shouldn’t take this as an indication of my alignment outside the particular and very unusual circumstances that constitute this election.
My position is that, no matter your opinions on any political issues , Clinton is more likely to be a better candidate than Trump in terms of implementing them. No matter where you fall on the various political spectra, you have a better shot with Clinton. If you’re a marxist, or a neocon, or a neonazi, or a randian libertarian, or you really want the united states to become a zoroastrian theocracy, you’re better off voting for Clinton.
Here’s the thing. Trump isn’t very good at doing things. No matter what he tries to do, he’s pretty likely to fail; not only that, but he’s unlikely to be able to realize that he’s failed. His mental model of the universe is so disconnected from reality that he believes himself to be a successful businessman. So, if you already agree with his positions, you can’t expect him to successfully implement them. On the off chance that he succeeds in some task, it’s difficult to determine which task it will be, and once he starts something, he can not be dissuaded from continuing. In other words, voter opinion can not influence him. His positions are arbitrary and change often, but they are quite importantly not based on any kind of outside influence: if he accidentally stumbles upon some policy that’s, say, a war crime (as he has), he won’t be convinced out of it; likewise, if he stumbles upon a highly unpopular policy, its unpopularity won’t convince him to abandon it. A Trump presidency is like electing a random number generator: it’s unpredictable, can’t be reasoned with, and although it’s technically unbiased the best possible case is that it will be entirely ineffective.
Compare this to Clinton. Hillary is extremely effective as an administrator, and seems to want power for the sake of demonstrating her ability to wield it rather than for any particular end. While effectiveness in of itself is a double-edged sword in a politician, Hillary has a couple other attributes that make her power much more likely to be wielded for good. Specifically, she has a tendency to make her positions mirror that of the general population — in other words, to flip-flop in order to mirror popular sentiment (if you want to paint it negatively) — and she’s concerned in a fairly realistic way with how history will remember her. By following public opinion, she’s unlikely to perform actions that are terribly unpopular based on some kind of flawed personal conviction; however, her concern with posterity lowers the rate at which she would advocate things that may be popular in the moment but will almost certainly end up seeming terrible to future generations. To use a concrete example, she’ll publicly support gay marriage even if she privately disagrees because she knows that gay marriage is only going to continue to grow in support, but she will never support legislation like that proposed by Trump to ban the immigration of muslims (even though this would not be illegal per-se & has precedent in the Alien Act) even if it’s highly popular with the electorate because such bans will always look bad at some point in the future.
While people criticize the candidates for being weak in either confidence or implementation, there’s really only one circumstance in which a leader that has a set of strongly held positions that they implement effectively is desirable: when you agree with all those positions to a greater degree than the leader does. A strong leader with unpopular positions is a disaster of a dictator; we would rather a leader with positions with which we disagree be ineffective, because then his or her decisions would be irrelevant. Alternately, a leader whose policies are flexible but whose ability to enact policy is good can be bent to the will of the people, and becomes a tool of the people: an even better result. In a sense, to the degree that leaders are strong, we wish them to be corrupt in a very specific way: weak to the forces of popular sentiment now and in the future, but strong against the kind of organizations that exist to warp politicians’ sense of what positions have popular support (industry lobbying groups and such).
By John Ohno on September 29, 2016.
[Canonical link](https://medium.com/@enkiv2/the-political-post-ive-been- avoiding-writing-7e8d4ee75679)
Exported from Medium on September 18, 2020.
What would you do if you were an archer and you had only two arrows (maybe [[one green, one red]])? Maybe declared to be your only two arrows through reliable prophecy. What would you shoot in the direction of, and how would your time your shots?
What if I die come Monday, I ask myself? And I smile. Then I would have only two days left and I should make them count. Which of course applies to every day in principle.
(I am reminded of the [[secretary problem]], which in my mind could be called the [[fiancee problem]].)
Into the fourth pomodoro already at 15:10, feeling great. I’m glad I’m doing this on the 20th instead of the 27th or the 30th. I feel like I’m living in the future — always a nice feeling :)
Took a long break, starting fifth pomodoro at 15:55.
Oh, I’ll [[burn]] if I have to.
I’ll burn myself for good if I can and be happy while I do it, or at least [[free from suffering]].
I’m on the seventh, did some [[catharsis]] and thinking on [[consciousness]] with [[daniel dennett]] — and laundry, which I had planned on doing and wrote down as an intent prior, so that was part of the day’s work :)
Now on to [[agora rfcs]].
Eight went well :)
Also collected laundry (started in six, so some loss of time, but not major) and in the rest had a bite.
I’m drinking [[mate]].
Today is Sunday [[2022-08-21]]. I’m back in this node again :)
I’ve done four pomodoros today, now I’m about to begin my fifth. It’s 16:40.
Towards this number I’ve not counted the 1.5h of solid coworking with [[bouncepaw]] in [[agora meet]] this morning, which happened thanks to him and was great.
(This block could have been a push from my [[daily]], and the Agora could have rendered it as another update in this timeline without too much extra work.)
I noded [[writing pomodoro]], which is one of a kind I’m about to do.
Back here on the [[2022-08-28]], happy for it. [[Working in public]] with friends! A [[dream]] come true.
Back here on the [[2022-08-31]]. Yesterday I stayed up late finish work before holidays. Today I’m focusing on [[agora doc]], the deliverable for [[agora pkg chapter]].
Did a diagram in [[excalidraw]], checked some references, discussed some feedback with [[st]] in the morning.
Now on to edit for one pomodoro :)
[[agora diagrams]] is improving, I’m happy about it. I shared one with [[ladee]] and [[agora discuss]].
Here again on [[2022-09-04]] while on the train to Lisbon. There’s plenty to do, enough that I could feel overwhelmed, but somehow I mostly feel happy instead. I have this 2h (remaining) trip in front of me and I’ll try to make the most of it.
The term [[data sovereignty]] as per [[wp]] seems to be mostly taken over already by states?
-> [[digital self-determination]], already noded by [[neil]] :D
(As I write this I listen to [[prizewinning]] by [[Juliana Barwick]].)
[[agora graph]]
Back here while [[today]] resolves to [[2023-12-18]] :)
Finally I’ve added support for — resulting in an hr element in the Agora, I think I have a bug, let’s see :)
Fixed now using [[smartypants]] to process — as em-dash whenever it’s in-sentence :)
-> thinking of [[Right Speech]]